- STR Scout โ Your Insider Guide to STR Deals, Real Estate Market Trends, and Travel Investing.
- Posts
- ๐ฅ STR Recession Buzz, Airbnb vs. Vrbo, Confidence Dive
๐ฅ STR Recession Buzz, Airbnb vs. Vrbo, Confidence Dive
The Top 10 STR Homes for Sale
Consumer confidence just took a nosediveโand wallets are tightening. What does it mean for STRs and the housing market? We've got the latest trends, top deals, and economic signals every buyer, seller, and investor should watch right now.
In this issue:
๐ฅ STR Classifieds โ This weekโs Top 10 most-clicked short-term rental deals.
๐ Spending Slowdown โ Consumer cutbacks are here. How will it hit STR bookings?
๐ฐ STR News Nuggets โ Fast, must-know headlines shaping real estate and rentals.
๐ Housing & Economic Update โ Recession signals grow louder. Hereโs this weekโs data pulse.
Letโs dive in ๐
โ The STR Scout Team
๐ $312K | Perdido Key, FL: 1BD/1BA + bunk alcove condo at Grand Caribbean. Rare oversized L-shaped balcony with stunning Gulf & pool views. Fully furnished, updated, steps to beach. Turnkey rental! View Post.
๐ฟ $360K | Basye, VA: Updated 3BD/1.5BA cabin in Bryce 4 Season Resort. Renovated in 2022, fully furnished, includes garage, firepit & grill. Skiing, golf, hiking nearby. Turnkey STR or getaway! View Post.
๐ $425K | Peshastin, WA: Fully renovated 1BD/1BA riverfront condo near Leavenworth. Turnkey STR with new appliances, energy-efficient HVAC, stunning views, and high demand. Rare getaway gem! View Post.
๐ $445K | Indianapolis, IN: Active Airbnb in Fountain Square! 4BD/2.5BA, 1775 sqft, minutes to stadiums & Indy 500. $61K gross rev in 2024. Fully furnished, turnkey with garage. View Post.
โ๏ธ $449K | Navarre, FL: FSBO pool home near Navarre Beach! No HOA or rental restrictions. Saltwater pool, strong 2024 gross income of $51K. Great short-term rental potential. View Post.
๐ฒ $595K | Mammoth Cave, KY: 3 charming cabins on 4 acres across from Nolin Lake. $95K+ avg annual income, 100s of 5-star reviews. Room to expand, no rental restrictions. Turnkey cash cow. View Post.
๐๏ธ $625K | Ashford, WA: 2BD/1BA Airbnb built in 2023 near Mt. Rainier. Grossing $92K in 2024 w/ 9.9% cap rate. Fully furnished, hot tub, EV hookup, A/C, heat pump. Turnkey & high demand. View Post.
๐ $999K | St. Augustine, FL: Profitable 4BD/3BA vacation rental in historic Lincolnville. Walk to downtown, fully furnished, turnkey with $120K verified annual revenue. Strong reviews, high demand. View Post.
๐ข $1.039M | Pigeon Forge, TN: Two 2BD/2BA cabins (sleeps 14 total), built in 2023. Hot tubs, firepits, upgraded finishes, $113K Airbnb-only gross in 2024. 1 mi to Parkway, 3 mi to Dollywood. View Post.
โฐ๏ธ $1.45M | Sevierville, TN: 3 themed cabins on 1 lot, grossing $250K+ in 2024. Fully renovated, no HOA/restrictions, minutes to Pigeon Forge & Gatlinburg. Qualifies for multifamily loan. Turnkey STR gem! View Post.
๐ Consumers Are Spending SmarterโHereโs What It Means for Airbnb Hosts
๐ก Why it matters: Travel is still a priority, but consumers are becoming more selective about how they spend. Airbnb hosts need to adapt to shifting travel habits to remain competitive.
๐ By the numbers:
75% of consumers are trading down on purchases, up 1% from last year.
Gen X and Boomers still see travel as splurge-worthy.
International trips and cruises are gaining traction over domestic stays.
๐ What to watch:
Value-driven bookings โ Guests are price-conscious but will splurge on meaningful stays.
Last-minute deals โ More travelers are delaying purchases and hunting for discounts, at the last minute.
Unique experiences win โ Travelers want stays that inspireโhighlight your Airbnbโs best features and create and sell the experience over the property.
g๐ก The bottom line: Airbnb hosts should fine-tune pricing, emphasize value, and cater to evolving guest preferences. Consumers are still spending, but they have more choices and they expect more for their money.

Keeping Your Hand on the Pulse of STR, Airbnb, and Real Estate Markets.
๐ฅ Airbnb calls Vrbo billboards "confused and desperate" in the latest escalation of the vacation rental platform rivalry. The criticism comes as Vrbo launches a new advertising campaign targeting Airbnb hosts and guests, highlighting what it claims are superior features and benefits for users.
๐ Vrbo has released its annual list of top vacation rental destinations for 2025, showcasing trending locations that have seen significant booking growth. The list highlights emerging markets and provides valuable intel for property investors looking to expand their STR portfolio.
๐ผ Short-term rental policies and litigation continue to evolve across the United States, with numerous jurisdictions implementing new regulations or facing legal challenges to existing ones. These developments are creating a complex patchwork of rules that STR operators must navigate to remain compliant.
๐ Montreal has introduced strict new regulations limiting short-term rentals to summer months only, in a bold move to address housing shortages. The policy represents one of the most restrictive approaches to STR regulation in North America and could set a precedent for other cities facing similar housing challenges.
โ๏ธ An Airbnb host in New York faces manslaughter charges following a guest's death at their property, raising serious questions about host liability and safety standards. The unprecedented case could have far-reaching implications for hosts and platforms across the industry.
๐ Pool-sharing platform Swimply continues to gain popularity in Australia, offering homeowners a way to monetize their swimming pools by renting them hourly. This micro-STR concept demonstrates the expanding definition of what constitutes a rentable space.
๐ Travelers leaving Airbnb are increasingly seeking alternative vacation rental platforms that offer better safety standards and consistent quality. New platforms emphasizing property verification and guest protection are gaining market share as consumers become more discerning about their accommodation choices.
๐๏ธ Jersey Shore summer rental bookings are showing strong demand for the 2025 season, with many property owners reporting earlier reservations than in previous years. The continued strength in this seasonal market suggests vacation destinations remain resilient despite economic uncertainties.
๐ด Canadian snowbirds are selling their Florida condos due to rising insurance costs and property taxes, disrupting a long-established winter migration pattern. Many are exploring alternative sunbelt destinations or opting for shorter-term rental arrangements rather than ownership.
๐ Canadian visitors to Arizona remain a vital economic driver for the state's tourism and real estate sectors, though changing demographics and travel patterns are reshaping this traditional relationship. Property managers targeting this market should note shifts in length-of-stay preferences and amenity expectations.
๐ The U.S. rental market saw homeownership rates decline in Q4 2024, pushing the rentership rate to its highest level since early 2020. This trend supports continued demand for rental housing across various market segments.
๐๏ธ Florida could soon see an increase in housing supply through new legislation designed to address the state's affordability crisis. The proposed measures aim to streamline development processes and incentivize builders to create more entry-level housing.
๐ฎ Some real estate markets could see price decreases according to industry analysts, with certain overheated regions potentially experiencing significant corrections. Investors should closely monitor local market indicators rather than national trends.
๐ก The death of the starter home in Florida represents a troubling trend for first-time buyers, with affordable entry-level properties becoming increasingly scarce. This market shift has profound implications for younger generations' ability to build wealth.
๐ Private home sale listings are growing in popularity as sellers seek to avoid the traditional MLS process and associated commission structures. This emerging "pocket listing" trend presents both challenges and opportunities for STR investors looking for off-market properties.
๐ Southwest Florida's housing market is experiencing a massive inventory surge, raising questions about sustainability and potential price corrections. The unexpected boom in available properties suggests a significant shift in this previously tight market.
๐จ The end of South Florida's real estate dream may be approaching according to some economists, with climate concerns and insurance costs threatening long-term property values. Investors in coastal markets should consider these factors when evaluating the durability of their investments.
๐ Realtors are highlighting multiple reasons why moving to Florida remains attractive despite recent market challenges, focusing on lifestyle benefits and tax advantages. This ongoing migration supports continued demand for both long-term housing and vacation rentals.
๐ Home price indices for February 2025 show continued appreciation in many markets despite higher interest rates, demonstrating the persistent supply-demand imbalance. These price trends support the investment thesis for quality STR properties in desirable locations.
๐ฆ The Federal Reserve held interest rates steady at its latest meeting, citing ongoing economic uncertainty and mixed inflation data. This pause provides some stability for real estate investors while markets await clearer direction on future monetary policy.
๐ Some homebuyers are hoping for a recession to bring down housing prices, though economists caution that the relationship between economic downturns and real estate values is complex and varies by market. Strategic investors should prepare for multiple economic scenarios.
๐๏ธ Homebuilders are avoiding large-scale layoffs despite slowing sales, suggesting confidence in a market recovery once interest rates decline. This workforce retention strategy indicates the industry anticipates stronger demand in the coming quarters.
๐๏ธ The optimal time to list your home for sale in 2025 varies by market, but generally falls in late spring for most regions. Property owners considering transitions between personal use and STR status should time their moves strategically.
๐ฒ Home equity loan rates have fallen again, creating opportunities for property owners to access capital for renovations or additional investments. This financing trend could support quality improvements across the STR inventory.
๐๏ธ Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are undergoing significant board restructuring, which could impact mortgage market liquidity and investor lending programs. These changes at the GSEs warrant attention from anyone involved in real estate financing.
๐จ New tariffs could impact home construction costs and ultimately housing prices, according to industry analysts monitoring recent trade policy developments. These potential cost increases may affect both new development and renovation budgets.
๐ New Orleans' economic and real estate outlook shows mixed signals according to forecasts presented at a recent industry seminar. The city's unique market dynamics continue to offer distinctive opportunities for specialized STR operators.
๐ Slower economic growth appears likely according to the latest CNBC Fed Survey, with recession risks increasing. Property investors should consider how various economic scenarios might affect both short and long-term rental demand.
๐ American retirees are increasingly looking to Mexico as an affordable alternative to traditional domestic retirement destinations. Cancun and Playa del Carmen are seeing particular interest, creating investment opportunities for STR properties targeting this demographic.
๐ด Central American cities are emerging as retirement hotspots for North Americans seeking lower costs of living and favorable climates. These international trends are creating new markets for property investors willing to explore beyond traditional boundaries.
As market conditions continue to evolve rapidly across the STR landscape, staying informed on these intersecting trends will be crucial for maintaining competitive advantage. We'll be watching closely as these stories develop to bring you the latest insights in our next edition.
Stay tuned for the latest STR business, travel and lifestyle news.
๐ Weekly Housing & Economic Trends
March 17-21, 2025
This week, the U.S. housing market exhibited mixed signals. Mortgage rates edged higher, potentially dampening buyer enthusiasm, while housing inventory continued its upward trend, offering more options to prospective homeowners. Concurrently, economic indicators reflected growing recessionary pressures, with consumer sentiment reaching a multi-year low and inflation expectations on the rise.
๐ก Housing Market Trends
Event | Actual | +/- | Prior | YoY |
---|---|---|---|---|
30-Yr | 6.65% | +0.02% | 6.63% | -0.09% |
15-Yr | 5.80% | +0.01% | 5.79% | -0.29% |
HMI | 42 | -5 | 47 | -5 |
Starts | 1.366M | -0.149M | 1.515M | -0.027M |
Permits | 1.483M | +0.001M | 1.482M | -0.001M |
Rent | $1,580 | 0 | $1,580 | -6.5% |
Inv. | 1.18M | +3.5% | 1.14M | +16.8% |
๐ Economic Calendar
Date | Event | Actual | Prior |
---|---|---|---|
Mar 10 | CPI | 0.3% | 0.5% |
Mar 11 | JOLTS | 6.9M | 7.1M |
Mar 12 | PPI | 0.4% | 0.6% |
Mar 13 | Jobless | 220K | 210K |
Mar 14 | Sentiment | 57.9 | 65.2 |
๐ Key Takeaways:
Mortgage Rates: The 30-year fixed rate rose slightly to 6.65%, ending a seven-week decline, adding marginal pressure to affordability.
Inventory Surge: Housing inventory jumped 3.5% this week and is now up 16.8% year-over-year, expanding buyer options.
Builder Confidence: The Housing Market Index dropped to 42, signaling declining optimism amid affordability and labor concerns.
Inflation Trend: CPI and PPI cooled slightly in February, providing some breathing room for the Fed on the inflation front.
Labor Softness: Jobless claims rose and job openings declined, indicating gradual loosening in the labor market.
Consumer Sentiment: The University of Michiganโs index plunged to 57.9โits lowest since 2022โreflecting elevated economic anxiety.
Fed in Focus: With the next FOMC meeting approaching, the Fed faces mounting pressure to pivot as growth slows. Markets expect the Fed to hold rates steady but signal a dovish turn if weak labor and sentiment data persist.
๐ Market Outlook
The combination of rising mortgage rates, increasing housing inventory, and declining consumer confidence suggests emerging recessionary pressures. Potential investors may face higher borrowing costs, while sellers might need to adjust price expectations amid a cooling market and surging inventory.
Sources: Data compiled from recent economic releases WSJ and AP.
Thank you for being a valued subscriber in our community and for sharing us with your friends and business associates.
If you are interested in advertisting your property or sponsoring our newsletter please email us at [email protected].
Have a great week!